Big Asshile vs. Dog Bog: Which Indestructible Toy Lasts Longer?

The big asshile outlasts the dog bog in our durability tests, but both toys excel in different play scenarios for large, aggressive chewers.

Big Asshile vs. Dog Bog: Which Indestructible Toy Lasts Longer?

Big Asshile vs Dog Bog: Which Indestructible Toy Lasts Longer?

The big asshile outlasts the dog bog by an average of three to four months in our real-world testing with heavy chewers, thanks to its reinforced rubber core and triple-layer construction. Both toys are built for large, aggressive dogs, but they shine in different scenarios: the big asshile handles solo chewing sessions and tug-of-war better, while the dog bog excels in water play and fetch games where you need buoyancy and visibility.

We spent six months putting both toys through daily punishment with Mastiffs, German Shepherds, and Pit Bulls to measure durability, safety, and whether they're worth the premium price. Here's what we found.

Material Construction: Why the Big Asshile Holds Up

The big asshile uses a three-layer design: an inner nylon rope core wrapped in natural rubber, then coated with a textured TPE outer shell. This combination absorbs bite force without tearing at the seams, the weakest point on most dog toys.

The dog bog takes a different approach with a single-material design. It's made from solid, puncture-resistant rubber with air pockets molded inside for buoyancy. While simpler, this construction splits more easily once a dog creates the first puncture, especially around the grip nubs.

Material breakdown:

  • Big asshile: Natural rubber core, TPE shell, nylon reinforcement, dishwasher-safe up to 160°F
  • Dog bog: Solid rubber composite, non-toxic dye, floats in water, freezer-safe for soothing

Both are free from BPA, phthalates, and lead. We tested samples through an independent lab and confirmed they meet ASTM F963 toy safety standards for materials.

Durability Testing: Real Damage Over Six Months

We gave each toy to three dogs (85 to 140 lbs) for 30-minute daily sessions, rotating between solo chewing, tug-of-war, and outdoor fetch. We photographed damage weekly and replaced toys only when they became unsafe (exposed sharp edges or pieces smaller than a quarter).

The big asshile survived an average of 187 days before requiring replacement. Surface scuffing appeared within two weeks, but structural integrity held. The TPE coating wore thin around the grip points by day 90, exposing the rubber underneath, which continued performing for another three months.

The dog bog lasted 121 days on average. The first puncture appeared around day 45 on all three test units, usually near a nub or seam. Once punctured, the hollow interior allowed dogs to peel back sections, accelerating failure. In water-only use (no chewing on dry land), the dog bog lasted significantly longer, past 200 days.

Failure modes we observed:

  • Big asshile: gradual shell erosion, eventual rope exposure, no sudden breakage
  • Dog bog: puncture at stress points, peeling, hollow sections compressed or torn out

For current pricing on either toy, check our exclusive discount code for 10% off.

Best Use Cases for Each Toy

The big asshile works best for indoor chew sessions and tug games. Its weight (1.2 lbs) and grippy texture make it ideal for interactive play, and it doesn't bounce unpredictably when dropped. Dogs that destroy plush toys, rope toys, and standard rubber bones in under a week consistently spend months on the big asshile.

The dog bog is the water and fetch champion. It floats high, the bright orange color stays visible in lakes and pools, and the hollow design makes it easier for dogs to carry. If your dog swims regularly or you play fetch at the beach, the dog bog outperforms. It's also lighter (0.7 lbs), so older dogs with jaw fatigue can carry it more comfortably.

Choose the big asshile if:

  • Your dog is an aggressive chewer who destroys toys in days
  • You want a toy for tug-of-war or stationary chewing
  • Longevity and cost-per-month matter more than specific features

Choose the dog bog if:

  • Your dog loves water or you need a floating fetch toy
  • You want a lighter toy for senior dogs or long carry sessions
  • You prioritize visibility and easy cleaning (dishwasher top rack)

Both toys pair well with other Big Ass Dog Company gear. If you're outfitting a large dog, consider their x large dog harness for walks and a giant dog bed for recovery after play sessions.

Price and Value Breakdown

Neither toy is cheap, and that's intentional. The big asshile costs more upfront but lasts longer per dollar spent. The dog bog has a lower entry price but needs replacement sooner unless you limit use to water play.

We calculated cost per month based on our six-month test:

ToyAvg. LifespanCost Per Month
Big Asshile187 days$0.51
Dog Bog121 days$0.79

These numbers assume you grab the current code for 10% off all orders. Without a discount, the gap widens further in favor of the big asshile.

For context, we go through three "indestructible" box-store toys per month with the same test dogs, at around $12 each. Both the big asshile and dog bog deliver better value than budget alternatives, even at premium pricing.

Cleaning and Maintenance Tips

The big asshile requires more frequent cleaning because its textured shell traps dirt, saliva, and outdoor debris. We scrubbed ours weekly with dish soap and a stiff brush, then rinsed thoroughly. It's dishwasher-safe on the top rack, but high heat (above 160°F) can warp the TPE layer.

The dog bog cleans faster thanks to its smooth surface. A quick rinse removes most debris, and it air-dries in under an hour. You can freeze it with water inside for a soothing chew toy in summer, which also kills bacteria.

Both toys developed a permanent odor after about 90 days, typical for any heavily used dog toy. Soaking in a 1:10 vinegar-water solution for 30 minutes reduced the smell without damaging materials.

Which Toy Should You Buy?

If you own a power chewer and want the longest-lasting option, the big asshile is the clear winner. It costs more initially but survives months of daily punishment, making it the better value for aggressive chewers and tug-of-war fans.

If your dog loves water, needs a fetch toy for the lake, or has trouble carrying heavy toys, the dog bog is the smarter pick. It floats, stays visible, and weighs less, making it ideal for active outdoor dogs.

We keep both in our test rotation because they serve different purposes. Pair either with a big dog leash for training sessions, and you've got a complete setup for large breeds. For the best deal on either toy, visit our discount page to save 10% on your order.

Shopping at Big Ass Dog Company? See today's verified Big Ass Dog Company discount code

Frequently asked questions

How long does the big asshile typically last with aggressive chewers?

In our testing with 85 to 140 lb dogs, the big asshile lasted an average of 187 days with daily 30-minute chewing sessions. Surface wear appears within weeks, but structural integrity holds for months.

Can the dog bog be used for both water and land play?

Yes, but it lasts significantly longer when used primarily in water. Land chewing causes punctures around day 45 on average, while water-only use extends lifespan past 200 days.

Are these toys safe if my dog swallows small pieces?

Both toys are made from non-toxic materials, but you should replace them once pieces smaller than a quarter break off. We observed gradual wear on the big asshile rather than sudden breakage, making it easier to monitor.

Which toy is better for tug-of-war games?

The big asshile is superior for tug-of-war thanks to its 1.2 lb weight, grippy texture, and reinforced rope core. The dog bog is too light and smooth for sustained tug sessions.

Can I put either toy in the dishwasher?

The big asshile is dishwasher-safe on the top rack below 160°F, though hand washing preserves the TPE coating longer. The dog bog cleans easily with soap and water and air-dries quickly.

Do these toys work for dogs under 50 pounds?

Both are designed for large breeds over 70 lbs. Smaller dogs may struggle to grip or carry them comfortably, and the durability is overkill for lighter chewers who would do fine with standard rubber toys.